INKWELL NEWSWATCH 
Monthly Online eZine  
News And Views For Working Writers

INdex 
 
 INside Scoop
 
 ON THE COVER
 
 INside AUTHORS
 
 COLUMNS
 IN Her Own Write
 INscribe
 Pen IN Hand
 Write On!
 INstruction
 
 WRITER'S LIFE
 Fiction
 Nonfiction
 Screen & Stage
 Poetry
 
 TOOL KIT
 Top 10 Resources
 Advice/Q&A
 Features
 Book Reviews
 Items Of INterest
 Global Offerings
 INside Services
 
 INside CHUCKLES
 Bill The Bard
 The Writer At Work
 Games & Puzzles
 
 FREEdom STUFF
 Classifieds
 Syndication
 Classic eTexts
 Free Software
 IN Banners
 
 ABOUT IN
 Who's IN
 What's IN
 Submissions
 Editorial Calendar
 Advertising
 Join IN's Team
 Contacting IN

IN Front Cover




Search

Learn To Be A Better Journalist

Buy Classic Literature Collections

Acclaimed Screenplay Writing Software

Books On How To Write Fiction

Become A Well Paid Travel Writer



Vote daily and raise our ranking!


COLUMNS
INscribe
January, 2008


Free Writing Resources!


Literary Fictions Part I
What does "literary" and "mainstream" mean, anyway?
By  Jennifer Edelson

S
ome people turn up their noses at commercial, or mass-market fiction, and any author who writes it. 

Forget the mega-bucks commercial fiction rakes in, or the billions it entertains; if a book is predictable or plot driven, it's a rotten egg.

These people are literary elitists. And to a literary elitist, mass market — or paperback —  equals mentally challenged.

There are also plenty of folks who won't read a book unless, "it's about something." Ask them to think beyond plot, or to muddle through an underlying philosophy, and well... don't get me started. To these selective people, if the prose is too big or the story too realistic, the book is too "literary" (err, boring). See, if you have to reflect, it isn't entertainment.

So is it better to write really well about nothing much? Or tell a fairly superficial, but super entertaining, story?

Having just come back from Japan, where everything, and I mean everything, is trimmed, clipped, served, wrapped, worn and built to aesthetic, but also functional, perfection, I have to ask; is writing really that black and white? Why can't a novel be entertaining and well written, deep and fast-paced, pretty, philosophical and mainstream? And why draw such an indelible line between form and function?

And just what does "literary" and "mainstream," mean anyway?

Clearly, at the root of all this snootiness are assumptions about what makes "literature" literature and vise versa. I had no clue. But after some in-depth analysis (read, a brief search of the Internet and several minutes of soul searching) I've come up with a short list of several supposed distinctions. Some make sense; some would make a good baloney sandwich.

Allow me to break it down for you:

Literary fiction

  • Takes a more complex view of life, and often presents internal (sometimes moral) conflict that requires some level of philosophical reflection from both the writer and the reader.
  • Emphasizes characterization, and offers the reader more multi-dimensional personalities.
  • Is more interested in exploring humanity and its central themes. To this end, literature is more likely to strive at broadening a reader's relationship with life and universal human experience.
  • Tends to be introspective and slower paced.
  • Often makes use of passive voice, descriptive prose, metaphor and symbolism to set the stage and tell the story.
  • Uses language and words that are figurative, symbolic, evocative, and poetic to provoke the reader's response and manipulation emotion.
  • Is concerned with writing style and unique forms of narrative.
  • Doesn't always have a resolution (i.e. no happy ending).

Commercial, or mainstream fiction

  • Is typically plot-driven and focused on an event, or series of events, more so than character.
  • Has an obvious plot/theme and often relies on stereotypical characters and archetypal situations (good versus evil, in-love versus lonely) to tell a story.
  • Often contains satisfying characters that are easy to identify with.
  • Predictably typecasts the world and humanity.
  • Is more likely to challenge its characters with unlikely, or extraordinary problems, or place them in unlikely situations that have clever but fairly predictable solutions.
  • Utilizes a faster paced, traditional narrative — narrative that goes from point A to B, chapters without paragraph breaks, etc. 
  • Tends to be much more strategic, or purposeful, and thus more structured.
  • Contains escapist qualities (like an action movie).
  • Uses less complex language.
  • Typically concludes with a happy, or at least resolved, ending.
  • Usually draws a bigger audience, and as such, make a bigger profit than literary fiction.

According to Jerry Jackson Jr, assistant editor at Writer's Digest, "One of the easiest ways to determine whether your work is literary or commercial is to ask yourself, 'Will my book be assigned reading in college English classes, or will it be sold in grocery stores?'"

Ahem... are we saying that one is necessarily better than the other? Arbitrarily assigning worthiness based on class distinctions?

And what determines whether a book is grocery store bound or college English worthy?

Personally, I've spent as many good nights with King and Grisham (if not learned more from them), as I have with Nabokov and Bronte. And I'm not saying they don't have thematic and stylistic differences, but I do submit that these writers are equally talented, and that one is no less engrossing and creative than the other. In different words, they're all worthy reads, and I'd be ecstatic to write even half as well as any of them.

In my opinion, the quote below, reprinted from Writers Weekly sums the issue up best:

"Literary fiction is character driven and connotes a certain attention to the writing itself. Commercial or genre fiction is plot driven and while there is excellent writing in commercial or genre fiction, that's not its selling point. It's a big argument really. A lot of literary writers use plots, a lot of commercial writers can write one heckuva gorgeous sentence. Basically . . . it's in the eye of the beholder/reader/critic."
— M.J. Rose, Author of The Halo Effect.

Whether unique or boilerplate, fast or slow paced, profound or superficial, what matters is that a writer fleshes out, develops and records his idea in some way that does the reader a service.

If it resonates, whether way deep down or on some level akin to going on vacation, in my opinion, whether its won a Pulitzer prize or a place at the checkout isle, it's good, and thus "worthy" writing.
IN Icon


Jennifer Edelson is a former practicing Minnesota attorney, now regular IN columnst, freelance writer and legal writing professor. Her writing has appeared on all the finest refrigerators in the Twin Cities. Jennifer can be emailed at: raceyipsa@msn.com

Sign Up and Use Our New Forums! Voice Your Opinion! Discuss Our Content! Ask for Writing Assistance. Post Your Successes, Queries or Information Requests. Collaborate with Other Writers.

© Freelance Writing Organization - International 1999-2049

INscribe
IN This Issue
Creative Karma
Rejected! Now What?
Seven Deadly Sins
Seven Virtues
Essential Ingredients
The Last Quill
Done At Last!
Part III: It's A Fact
Part II: It's A Fact
Part I: It's A Fact

Support IN
Receive Free Gifts
$20.00 Voluntary Contribution
$35.00 Voluntary Contribution
$50.00 Voluntary Contribution

New Novelist Software


Effectively Manage Your List


Writers Digest 101 Site Award






Your Ad Here

Traffic Swarm For Writers


Hottest Books This Month!

Whose Books Are Turning Into Movies?
Bald Ego
Mouse Over To Pause

Writer’s Block
The path to inspiration starts
Upon the trails we’ve known;
Each writer’s block is not a rock,
But just a stepping stone.

Poetry Is Not
Penned to the page
Waiting for us to admire.
It is only a lonely thought
Caught by tears on fire.

Silent Echoes
A quiet rhyme upon a page
Is what a poet gives;
Some gentle words whispered in trust
To see if memory lives.

Bard From Deadlines
What makes a poem finally work
Is not the time it takes;
It’s how the poet used the muse
To prophet from mistakes.

Be Mused
The art and craft of poetry
Are not so far apart;
The craft comes from the cunning,
The rest comes from the heart.

Fine Vintage
Don’t plant your poem on the page
As though you’re hanging drapes;
It’s shape and flow should come and grow
Like wild summer grapes.

Getting It Write
Writers write what they know best,
Their passions, fears, and dreams;
Writers rarely write about
What other call their “themes.”

Double Vision
A writer’s life is paradox,
It’s more than what it seems;
We write of our reality,
The one inside our dreams.

Poetry
The echo of a promise,
The thunder of a sigh,
The music of a memory,
A child asking why.

Letter Perfect
Twenty six symbols arranged on a page
Can send a soul to heaven or torment it with rage,
Can free a fragile world or hold it in its net--
The power and the magic of the mighty alphabet.

The Write of Passage
The jump from writing just for fun
To getting paid for it
Begins when you first realize
You know you’ll never quit.

Pegasus
It is not the magic of his wings
That sets us free from our bond.
It is the muse within ourselves
That lets our words lift us beyond.

Photo Poet
Consider your mind the darkroom,
Consider your life the lens,
Consider your eye the camera
On whose focus the poem depends.

Rising Moon
A poem is a rising moon
Shining on the sea,
An afterglow of all we know,
Of all we hope to be.

Star Light
Writing a poem,
Reaching a star,
In making good art
We find who we are.

Spider Web
A poem is a spider web
Spun with words of wonder,
Woven lace held in place
By whispers made of thunder.

Re-Verse
The final draft upon the screen,
At last my poem’s through;
A verse of only four short lines--
I rewrote twenty-two!

Read All Of Charles Ghigna's Poetry at FatherGoose.com


Our Own Banner Rotator System
Any banner seen below is either our own or one of our members.
Support the cause - click a banner.


Want Your 468x60 Banner Above? It's FREE For Newly Published Books

© Freelance Writing Organization - International 1999-2049
All Rights Reserved. Copying in any way strictly forbidden.
Our Disclaimer Is Based Upon McIntyre's First Law: "Under the right circumstances, anything I tell you may be wrong."